), An eternal place, good but not heaven (an eternal Earth, Hel, etc. A girl asked atheist Richard Dawkins one day, “What if you’re wrong?” Aren’t you worried about going to hell?” Obviously, since I am an Atheist, I don’t believe in hell, but the point being made by the believer is that I might be wrong, and if I am, I would be in a lot of trouble. Ok, first of all, this movie looks extremely sacrilegious and like nothing that I would ever want to see or support. May 2, 2017 May 5, 2017 allscott. Evolution does not favor the good, it favors the “good enough for now” or the “slightly better than it was before”. It’s Time We Graduated from the Electoral College. What if it's the wrong answer, how would you know? All the other religions and religious people have a relationship with their God too. What If You’re Wrong. What if you’re wrong? But what I was most struck by was the assumption that, since you might be wrong, the conservative or traditionalist objector’s stance should be adopted as the default position. Let's say Christianity was right and you find this out on the Day of Judgement, what will you do? Calipari shows tepid support for player protests . Questioning deep-seated beliefs is terrifying. What If You’re Wrong? So we live according to Islam. The tremendously well-received New York Times bestseller by cultural critic Chuck Klosterman, exploring the possibility that our currently held beliefs and assumptions about the world will eventually be proven wrong -- now in paperback. What if you're right? You may resist self-skepticism because you believe it gives ground to wrong and dangerous ideas. The day is sponsored by the Secular Student Alliance, and is intended to be …. Depending on which god or gods happens to be real, we each could end up in a variety of different places or states of being: Sometimes, if not most of the time, the question is intended to be coercive. You're Wrong About Mike and Sarah are journalists obsessed with the past. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Believers can't admit they could be wrong because that goes against the idea of faith. Surely most, if not all, of those must be false! The event is intended to be an opportunity for the general public – particularly people of faith – to approach nontheists and ask questions about secular life. Instead of guessing how this new year will go, what might happen if you just assume you'll be wrong? A slightly more interesting way to approach this question, and one that may very well have been intended by the asker, would be to interpret it as asking “What will be the consequences if you are wrong?” And “consequences” are usually intended to mean “long-term consequences”, or in other words, “what happens when you die?”. To that, I ask: “Well, what if YOU’RE wrong?” I know people think they’re being unique and clever by asking this question, but they’re not. Our ability to reason clearly is not perfect. Notice how evolutionary biologist and atheist author, Richard Dawkins, “answers” the question: You ask me what if I’m wrong? An especially common example of an appeal to consequences is known as Pascal’s Wager, in which the French philosopher and mathematician, Blaise Pascal, argues that one is better off believing in a god, or at least trying to believe or acting like you believe, even if there is no god. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. And life is short, the hereafter is long. The fact is, we are sometimes wrong. But the most interesting approach to this question, in my opinion, has nothing at all to do with the question itself or the answer, but rather the fact that the question is asked at all. The only thing he had to gain by being right, by stubbornly insisting that he doesn’t like it, is just that—more of the same. I have read your arguments and they are all good, however at the same time the Bible seems clear on its stance regardless of translation. What if you jump? Ask it when you feel threatened by foreign ideas. What I think is that he was bringing attention to the idea of intellectual honesty, of which philosopher Louis Guenin says: The day is sponsored by the Secular Student Alliance, and is … It is meant to try to convince you that there really is a god, or at least that you should believe there is a god. Lyrics to 'What If You're Wrong' by Ronna Reeves. Listen About News Support Find Us We're on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Stitcher and everywhere else podcasts live. What if you’re wrong? ), Temporary torment, until eternal bliss is earned (Zoroastrian hell, etc. Featured What If You're Wrong. My position is that I have not seen any good reason to believe there are any gods. November 25, 2017 kristimorris4911. A few days ago, April 20, 2017, was National Ask an Atheist Day. What if I’m wrong? What if there is more? For some reason I decided to recreate the popular \"What if you're wrong?\" clip on youtube featuring Richard Dawkins lecture in Lynchburg.\rWatch the full lecture here http://fora.tv/2006/10/23/Richard_Dawkins\r\rI did have some ideas for some different endings but I thought I would just keep it faithful to the original. What if there's more? The situation that the United States enjoyed from 1945 until recently was the most prosperous in (perhaps) the history of the world so far. Abandoning this idea halts progress. Eternal bliss (Valhalla, Heaven, Nirvana, etc. / What if you’re wrong, Vernon? What if you’re wrong about the great Juju in the bottom of the sea? – Facts are presented in an unbiased manner, and not twisted to give misleading impressions or to support one view over another; Ask yourself the question when you think you’ve settled on a position. But What If We're Wrong? What if it's true? I have been struggling with my own sexuality and whether or not being homosexual or “BI” or whatever is really OK in the Bible. I realize that’s a subtle difference. Get In Touch Mike and Sarah are on Twitter. You’re so wrong about so many things, in fact, that I’m beginning to wonder if you might be just plain stupid.” I don’t care what level of … / What if you’re wrong, David? What I think is that he was bringing attention to the idea of intellectual honesty, of which philosopher Louis Guenin says: I describe the kernel of intellectual honesty as a virtuous disposition such that when presented with an incentive to deceive, the agent will not deceive. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. I just saw a commercial for the movie "Religulous" with Bill Maher. So if I am wrong, then there is at least one god. ( Log Out /  Like x 4; A Vestigial Mote Well … Or, as historian Daniel J. Boorstin puts it: The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it is the illusion of knowledge. I don’t think I’m saying anything controversial when I say that whether something has good or bad consequences has no bearing whatsoever on whether or not it is true. Change ), Depending on which god or gods happens to be real, You’re not an atheist, are you? I don’t think he was avoiding answering, though he may have been. Just close your eyes? It might be nice to wish for good things to happen. Tags: atheism; creation? They don't need to be right or wrong, they have faith and that somehow defeats logic, which of course it doesn't. But at least I can admit that. He wouldn’t go hungry without prayers and he … ( Log Out /  He never actually answered the question. Click here for Dr. Guenin’s interesting, if lengthy, exposition on intellectual honesty. Had the urge to try my hand at some animation and some new software, I think it turned out quite well. About something. I received a few silly questions, but also a few semi-serious questions. ( Log Out /  What if you're wrong? Any of us could be wrong about things we believe to be true. Richard Dawkins - "What if you're wrong?" And that’s correct. *Side note: Saying “if I’m wrong then there’s a god” assumes, of course, that I am saying there is no god, which is technically not true. What if you’re praying to the wrong god, and every time you go to church and tithe, you’re just pissing her off? What If You're Wrong Lyrics: What if you’re wrong, Koresh? Instead of guessing how this new year will go, what might happen if you just assume you'll be wrong? Feel free to send me your ideas on amusing variations...\r\rOh and this should be viewable in full HD! Ask it when you’re engaging in contentious arguments. Most conversations about being an Atheist eventually come down to asking me the question “What if you’re wrong? Well then if you’re wrong, then you’ll have everything to lose. About everything. A good rule that no one anywhere follows, is to contemplate the consequences of being wrong before doing something. Every week they reconsider an event, person or phenomenon that's been miscast in the public imagination. (part 1) – All Things Scottish. Your relationship with God is invalid when pondering this question. But what if you're wrong? As an atheist, do you think Richard Dawkins answered the question in a satisfying way? The short answer is … if I’m wrong then there’s a god.*. Discussion in 'Religious Debates' started by thomas t, Dec 11, 2020. People often ask: What if you’re wrong about Jesus and I’m on a road to hell. I don’t usually write things like this, but in light of events from today and other events of this last year, I feel compelled to have this conversation. If you are wrong, this entire effort is FOR NOTHING. But, as I’ve argued before, you’ll be in a better position to actually make things better if your beliefs reflect reality rather than a wished-for world. I don’t like to be questioned, but of this, I am certain. As he said, “When you think you’re right, you shut yourself off from possibility.” One stood out as particularly interesting to me. I was also wrong about my chiropractor. You've been running As fast as you can And you've been looking for a place You can land so long “You’re wrong about me, and the little theories you have about people always end up being wrong. When we refuse to even consider the possibility that we are wrong, we fail the first of those four expectations, and may fail the second and third as well. And there’s no way to know if you’re doing enough, so you do as much as you can, because you are rational actor that behaves according to what will benefit you the most. “You’re wrong,” a friend of mine said. What if it's love? What if He's more than enough? I'm not a bad man. (A few sample examples: evidence of some variety, well written critique that is logically sound, nothing) I don’t think he was avoiding answering, though he may have been. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. What if you’re wrong about Jesus not being our Saviour and hope of eternal life in Heaven? ), Eternal torment (Hell, Gehenna, Hifhel, etc. The idea being that your non-belief implies such a horrible outcome that you should really consider switching and becoming a believer. He was wrong and now he has a new love. So I thank my friend for asking that very important question. For a deeper dive into that, follow the link above. And if you are not interested in progress, then please step aside and don’t hold the rest of us back. 'Masked Dancer' takes an unexpectedly serious turn If I am wrong, the Holy Spirit will simply pursue me with correction, go around and ahead me to thwart the misleading, and work in the lives of the LGBTQ community to lead them to, “repentance.” However, if you’re wrong… You have condemned, marginalized, persecuted, and falsely judged an entire group of God-imaged people. What if you’re wrong? What if there's hope You never dreamed of hoping for? Communists, Capitalists, lurkers and all those in between what would it take for YOU to say your belief, ideology, or etc is wrong? "What if you're wrong?" I stand corrected. We can't know everything, human beings aren't smart enough to. He never actually answered the question. It doesn’t really come up in formal debates, but it’s presented all the time in informal conversations, whether you’re visiting religious family or telling someone you’re an atheist for the first time. ), and some things with good consequences turn out to be false (e.g., sacrificing a goat will not end a drought, etc.). They say the cross Will only make a fool of you And what if it's true? What if you’re wrong? Photo: Nicole Harrington Unsplash. What If You’re Wrong. Most conversations about being an Atheist eventually come down to asking me the question “What if you’re wrong? That’s it, question answered. Complete Full Script, Dialogue, Remarks, Saying, Quotes, Words And Text. We rarely have all the facts of a given situation. yes 15 vote(s) 88.2% no 2 vote(s) 11.8% Top Posters. – Relevant facts and information are not purposefully omitted even when such things may contradict one’s hypothesis; The answer to that question is much more complicated, and would depend on which god I was wrong about (a part of the question that is often ignored). It is important to recognize that fact. When we adopt an intellectually honest stance, we are adopting a form of humility, a respect for yourself and others, and a commitment to the truth, all rolled into one. The boiler plate answer most atheists give is what if the believer is wrong about the other 1000’s of gods out there. is a question I was asked over Christmas by a Christian friend. Let's say Islam was right and you find this out on the Day of Judgement, what will you do? … an opportunity for secular groups across the country to work together to defeat stereotypes about atheism and encourage courteous dialogue between believers and nonbelievers alike. Answer the questions that the guy is asking. And He was just another nice guy What if you're right? How will you try to compensate for your lack of beliefs? ( Log Out /  A few days ago, April 20, 2017, was National Ask an Atheist Day. Paul M. Turner in Seeds of Hope. Our ability to perceive our environment is not perfect. In fact, the refusal to recognize that fact can be very damaging (and, as Guenin would characterize it, immoral). If you think the magic is gone Then I agree maybe You should move on If you're sure that your love for me has really died Report: Trump refusing to pay Giuliani for legal work. Some things with bad consequences turn out to be true (e.g., If you jump off a building you will be injured or killed, etc. But there is a portion of the ad for that movie that shows Bill being asked by someone, "What if you're… Nov 27, 1999 by Rev. What if you’re wrong about the great Juju in the bottom of the sea? Guest Post by The Zman. What if I’m wrong about everything? The answer is quite simple: it really depends on what you choose to believe. Source: LYBIO.net. A good rule that no one anywhere follows, is to contemplate the consequences of being wrong before doing something. If a god created the universe, I think he’d be confident enough to get by just fine without perpetual brown-nosing. Read or print original What If You're Wrong lyrics 2020 updated! To be or not to not be, that is the question. As well as this, how do YOU know YOU picked the right answer? “What if I’m wrong” is an important part of learning and improving. If… – References, or earlier work, are acknowledged where possible, and plagiarism is avoided. “But what if you’re wrong?” 2- As the believer becomes more familiar with the world, the ways of the world and being so much different from the rest of the world, he realizes that the question (“But what if you’re wrong?”) is occasionally asked as a question; i.e., the person asking the question is interested in hearing an answer. But that doesn’t seem like a very satisfying answer to me. What if there is something after this life? Is a question alot of theists like to ask us atheists. What if you’re wrong? Aren’t you worried about going to hell?” Obviously, since I am an Atheist, I don’t believe in hell, but the point being made by the believer is that I might be wrong, and if I … In the spirit of the day (no pun intended), I offered to answer any questions my Facebook friends had for me. I am working under the assumption that there is no god until I see some evidence that there is one, in much the same way I walk around every day assuming that I’m not about to die until I see some evidence that I am. Wikipedia gives a pretty good basic definition of intellectual honesty: Intellectual honesty is an applied method of problem solving, characterized by an unbiased, honest attitude, which can be demonstrated in a number of different ways: It’s based on the fact that we are not perfect, none of us. What if He takes His place in history With all the prophets and the kings Who taught us love and came in peace But then the story ends What then? And by everything, I mean mean eternal life with God. There’s a few different ways to approach a question like this. If you think that the stock market can’t go up, what if you’re wrong? What if the arms that catch you Catch you by surprise? If I am wrong, the Holy Spirit will simply pursue me with correction, go around and ahead me to thwart the misleading, and work in the lives of the LGBTQ community to lead them to, “repentance.” However, if you’re wrong… You have condemned, marginalized, persecuted, and falsely judged an entire group of God-imaged people. Let's say Atheism was right and you find this out somehow, what will you do? South Park - YouTube ), Reincarnation (possibly as a “higher” or “lower” life form), Nothingness (this is also the result if I’m right). 18:00 CET . Richard Dawkins – “What If You’re Wrong?”. Pascal’s Wager is one of the most popular defenses presented when you’re in an argument with a believer. (Austin Cunningham/Denise Davis) / If you think the magic is gone The most obvious approach, and also the least interesting in my opinion, is to just answer it directly. It is an important part of the scientific method. They say the first step to recovery is to recognize you have a problem. Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com. Even our most dearly held beliefs could be simply wrong. A status quo of disliking, when he could have exchanged it for unexpected delight. But see, I admit I could be wrong. Let's just imagine you're wrong in your beliefs. It doesn’t really impact what I am saying here, but it is worth mentioning. However, if you're wrong...you have a lot to worry about, my friend... Actually, a number of atheists who have done research have converted to Christianity...just look at Lee Strobel @Colonel Panic: Here, the question was addressed to Christians by an atheist...it was not addressed to 'people of all religions' so naturally, we would only discuss Christianity and atheism. What If You're Wrong To me, it is not important whether or not one is wrong believing in what one believes More important it is, that one learns to become a loving person, with or without religion #15 stvdv, Dec 11, 2020. As a result, we are hobbled with this jury-rigged brain that was built over the millennia with short-term fix after short-term fix. This is a guy who does everything wrong, according to political convention, yet comes out smelling like a rose. Well here's another Dawkins themed upload. – One’s personal beliefs do not interfere with the pursuit of truth; For example, look at all the conflicting views we found regarding the afterlife. Guest Post by The Zman. This is a logical fallacy known as an appeal to consequences: An appeal to consequences is an attempt to motivate belief with an appeal either to the good consequences of believing or the bad consequences of disbelieving. It seems to be sort… But what if you're wrong?